All Things Digital

Skip to main content.

Mossberg's Mailbox

Mossberg's Mailbox from The Wall Street Journal

Time Capsule Alternatives, Windows 7 and Using Droid in Europe

We’ve got two Apple iMacs. I planned to buy the Apple Time Capsule to back them up until I read online reports that some seem to just die after 18 months. Can you recommend another backup solution for a home Apple environment?

A: The built-in backup program in your iMacs, called Time Machine, doesn’t require Apple’s Time Capsule product to work. It will work with almost any brand of directly connected external hard disk.

For instance, I back up my home iMac to a Western Digital drive that’s connected to it via a cable.

As for hard-drive life, it’s my experience that many seem to die sooner or later, especially if they are used heavily. I don’t know if the ones inside the Time Capsule are especially fragile. But, in just the past six months, I’ve had an external hard disk from G-Tech die on me; seen an internal hard disk on my home Dell die for a second time; and discovered that the hard disk on my colleague’s MacBook died.

One way to protect against the failure of a local backup drive is to consider, in addition to using an external disk, backing up your data to an online backup service like Mozy, Carbonite or SugarSync.

My Dell has Microsoft Vista but I can upgrade free to the new Windows 7. However, I was told my antivirus software won’t be compatible and my email will change—the program will no longer be “Windows Mail.” What do you recommend?

A: I regard Windows 7 as much better than Vista, but you are correct that many antivirus programs will require upgrading and Windows Mail will go away during the upgrade. You’ll have to install a new email program, such as the very similar “Windows Live Mail,” which can import your messages. So, the question really is one of trade-offs. If you’re satisfied with Vista, and would rather not perform these program replacements, you should stand pat. If you don’t like Vista, and are anxious to replace it, then the hassles you describe could be worth it.

Will Office 2003 work with the new Windows 7 operating system?

A: Microsoft, which makes both products, says the answer is yes, though I haven’t tested it.

Is it possible that the Verizon Motorola Droid, which doesn’t work in Europe, could be turned into a “world phone” that could work on European cellphone networks via an app somebody might develop?

A: An app wouldn’t be able to do that for the current Verizon Droid. It’s a hardware issue.

Verizon’s Droid, like most Verizon phones, is built to run on a type of network called CDMA that isn’t used in Europe or most other countries outside the U.S., which use a network standard called GSM.

To run on these networks, the Droid, or any other current CDMA phone, would need an entirely different radio, or two radios, one for each type of network.

Verizon offers a handful of so-called “world phones,” which have both kinds of radios inside, but the Droid isn’t one of them. Motorola may well make a new model with two radios, or even a model with one radio that would work overseas, and I wouldn’t be surprised if it did so.

What could be done with an app is to allow the Droid to make so-called VOIP phone calls via the Internet.

In fact, while I haven’t checked, there may already be such an app for Android—the Droid’s operating system—that would do so. But, in many cases, making such Internet phone calls requires the user to be in range of a Wi-Fi network. Some carriers don’t allow such calls to be made over their cellular networks.

You can find Mossberg’s Mailbox, and my other columns, online for free at the All Things Digital Web site, http://walt.allthingsd.com.

We’ve launched a new commenting tool, Disqus. For the full story on all of its functionality, click here. To begin commenting right away, you can log in below using Facebook Connect or Disqus—you can also log in using an existing AllThingsD account. Learn more about how Disqus collects and uses information in connection with the comments tool.
  • Ben Rosenthal
    I recommend the well-tested hard disks and external enclosures offered by Other World Computing.
  • Larry Fox
    I have purchased a Buffalo Link Duo which is a two drive mirrored 2T system. I connect through my Airport Extreme WiFi router for backup. This has not yet worked well, but supposedly will circumvent problems with only a single backup drive.
  • mike Diaz
    a couple of comments.
    re: data backup, the user has several options.
    1) online backup portals google em there are plenty. you have to pay to use but it keeps an your files someplace else as offline storage.
    2) NAS, plenty of them out there, plug into your router and you see it as a netshare or mapped drive. they are pretty cheap for terabytes of storage. you can find them at staples or bestbuy or pretty much where hard drives are sold. (cheaper
    2) grab an old pc/box and install the largest hard drive, and linux. install samba and map a netdrive to it then you can copy all your windows files to it. Havent tried it with a mac. but it still should work. (cheapest)

    As for the Verizon Droid and International calls, I know if the phone uses other phone protocols aside from CDMA, HSPDA, 3G, it should be useable in Europe. I know folks on vz that took their work phones to Europe and it worked out ok.
    and supposedly a european droid is coming as well.
    http://features.csmonitor.com/innovation/2009/1...

    D
  • David Prozzo
    To the writer who is concerned that his antivirus program won't work with Windows 7: Microsoft Security Essentials is free, is nicely integrated with Windows 7, runs with very low resources, and has received good reviews. You might want to check this out instead of continuing to pay a subscription for an antivirus program.
  • Fred Hamranhansenhansen
    > grab an old pc/box and
    > install the largest
    > hard drive, and linux.
    > install samba

    The user is on a Mac. Time Machine is a better solution than this and requires less than 1% of the work.

    All you do is plug in a USB disk and click "Yes" when asked if the disk can be used for backups. The Mac will back itself up hourly from then on for the rest of its life, backing up only what has changed in the past hour each time. You can also "fly back in time" at any time within any Finder window to get an older version of any file within that window.

    In addition, if your hard disk goes and you need to restore your whole system, all you have to do is replace the faulty hard disk, boot from the Mac OS X installer disk, and plug on your Time Machine disk. The Mac OS X installer will work for a while to do the restore, but when it is done, you will have bit-for-bit the system you had before the hard disk failed. You'll have the same messy desktop filled with the same files you still haven't had a chance to put away.

    I had a hard disk go after about 2 months in my MacBook Air, but I lost no data at all due to Time Machine, so I am speaking from experience.

    A key thing to understand with hard disks is that they are unreliable for the first 3 months, then generally reliable for months 4-36, and then after that they are unreliable again. You always need to be backed up, but both very old and very new disks need special attention. Think of a new disk as being on probation, and an old disk as being ready for retirement.
  • mike Diaz
    > grab an old pc/box and
    > install the largest
    > hard drive, and linux.
    > install samba

    "The user is on a Mac. Time Machine is a better solution than this and requires less than 1% of the work."

    the original post said that the user wanted to back up 2 macs. I approached the users problem from a cost perspective. (cheap)

    As for the Time Machine, being the better solution, I disagree. Its still a software solution, residing on the host. this still requires Ram, CPU,and disk space to retrieve and restore from.
    The time capsule maybe a better solution in that its external to the pc/workstation. It does everything external to the data being written to and accessed. both are proprietary to MAC, but I feel its too expensive for the added cost to time value of money.

    Re: hard drives, yep I understand MTBF as well. Ive been lucky, setting up raids on netware and windows servers. My expectation is when I buy a hard drive I dont expect it to die in the first 90 days after purchase.

    Again, No Offense to anyone. this is just an opinion, and hope the user feels they have more then one option to approach a problem.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Search The Mossberg Archives

Latest Mossberg's Mailbox Videos

More Videos »


BlackBerry News and Reviews on All Things Digital

Click below to browse or search past editions of Walt and Katie's columns.

Personal Technology »

Walt's main column, written since 1991, in which he reviews hardware, software and web sites, and comments on technology issues.

Mossberg’s Mailbox »

Walt's weekly column in which he answers readers' questions.

The Mossberg Solution »

Edited by Walt and written by Katie Boehret, this is a guide to gadgets, web services and other consumer technologies.

Ethics Statement

Here is a statement of my ethics and coverage policies. It is more than most of you want to know, but, in the age of suspicion of the media, I am laying it all out.

Read more »