Defragmenting a Mac Hard Disk
Here are a few questions I’ve received recently from people like you, and my answers. I have edited and restated the questions a bit, for readability.
I have moved from a PC to the iMac. In the Windows environment, I felt a need to run utilities to clean out the registry and defragment the hard disk frequently. Is this also needed on the iMac? If so, what programs are recommended?
The Mac operating system, called OS X Leopard, doesn’t include a registry, which is a feature of Windows that holds information that programs need to operate properly. So there’s no need to clean or maintain any registry on a Mac.
Mac hard disks, like those on Microsoft (MSFT) Windows computers, can get fragmented — a condition in which parts of files are so scattered around on the disk that the disk runs slowly. However, the operating system has some under-the-covers features that generally obviate the need to run a defragmentation utility. In fact, Apple (AAPL), which calls defragmenting a disk “optimizing” it, flatly claims that “You probably won’t need to optimize at all if you use Mac OS X.” There are some Mac defragmentation utilities, but I don’t believe you will need them unless you have large numbers of extremely large files and almost no free disk space.
My son’s computer frequently gets infected with adware, pop-ups. Recently it was hit with a continuing pop-up ad called VirusHeat that touted itself as a solution to the computer’s problems. When I paid for VirusHeat, the problems went away. Is it legitimate?
According to numerous reports on the Web, including some from security companies, VirusHeat is a form of malicious or misleading software. It falls into a category that attempts to scare people into thinking their computers are badly infected, or exaggerates any problems you may have. This is a common tactic now used by creators of malware.
Some of these fake or misleading “security programs” may be designed merely to make you pay. Others may even be designed to install the very kinds of viruses, spyware or adware that they claim to fight.
I have updated to a new PC. My data are on a floppy disc. There is no floppy disc drive on this new computer. How can I transfer my data?
For around $25, you can buy an external floppy disk drive that plugs into a new PC using its standard USB port. If you do so, and connect it to the new PC, you should be able to copy your data to the new computer’s hard disk.
- You can find Mossberg’s Mailbox, and my other columns, online for free at the new All Things Digital web site, http://walt.allthingsd.com.






Comments
A quick comment about defragging in Windows: these days, the user does not need to! If you install one of the newer automatic defragmenters, it will intelligently and automatically defrag files in the background as required; without any hit in performance. Quite similar to the OSX I believe. Scheduling a defrag on Windows (XP or Vista) is now a thing of the past.
Regards,
Posted by Albert Koh at May 15th, 2008 at 8:23 am-Albert.
No need to buy a drive to transfer data from one pc to another. Network the computers, or use a server over the internet.
Posted by Tony Martin at May 15th, 2008 at 10:36 amexcellent - so, i just pay MORE money to defrag what doesn’t need to be defragged, wait - - - or - - - defrag with a 3rd a . . . wait . . . . i need different software for ? . . . . oh, heck w/it - I’m happy i bought a mac LOL
Posted by stani everett at May 19th, 2008 at 6:26 pmGiven my recent experiences using Western Digital drives with my Macs, I think more often of fragging them than defragging them.
Posted by Nicolas Martin at May 26th, 2008 at 4:11 pmJust out of curiosity I used defrag software for my 4 year old dual CPU G5 desktop. It ran for a very long time, and in the end made no difference in the disc access speed… and I have lots of large files.
There is a very useful tool for the Mac called OmniDiskSweeper. This identifies folders with large files, and large files themselves, allowing the user a very easy way to delete duplicate folders or files
Posted by Per Sjofors at May 28th, 2008 at 9:30 amDear Mr. Mossberg,
My business is thinking of switching to an online version of Quickbooks. Quickbooks suggests using Bootcamp or a virtualization program. Is this worthwhile or should I just buy a PC and use it for bookkeeping?
Gus Rancatore
Posted by Gus Rancatore at May 28th, 2008 at 11:32 amTscanini’s